From the Peanut Gallery

These are some e-mail comments we've received on our Unofficial PISD Page. Only obscenities are edited out, all other evidence of ignorance, illiteracy, and/or hostility remains as written by its author.

From:   tenchi@airmail.net[SMTP:tenchi@airmail.net]
Sent:   Sunday, July 21, 1996 2:18 PM
To:     dave@thielen.com
Subject:        Your page...

Your page *****!!! I am in PISD and it does **** but is nothing to laugh
at. Want to know what is laughable? Your HTML programing is really sad.
Reply:
Thank you for your thoughtful and constructive criticism ;-). With regard to your specific comments, several responses seem necessary:
  • HTML is not, technically speaking, programming.
  • Unlike PISD, we do not have a technology staff with a $1 million plus payroll. And if we did, we certainly would not have paid $16,000 to an outside consultant to do such a simple task as creating a web page (as PISD did.) Our page is written by a few folks with absolutely no prior experience with HTML, or programming, yet we beat PISD to the WWW, and still offer more information.
  • You're right. That is nothing to laugh at.

    Subject:  Re: First Grade Homework
    Date:     Thu, 26 Sep 96 09:59:12 -0500 (CDT)
    From:     mdavis@wbap.com (Mark Davis)
    To:       Tim Williams 
    
    Great page!  And yep, I gave the address.
    
    MD
    

    Subject: pisd
       Date: Mon, 4 Nov 1996 08:30:26 -0600
       From: David Semon 
         To: timw@airmail.net
    
    Reply-To: semon@comp.tamu.edu
    X-Mailer: Jed [0.98-0]
    
    I happen to be a former student of Plano High and some of what I see on your
    web page is truly depressing. Why I thought anything should have changed, I
    don't know. How can it be that so few of the staff have email? I've had
    e-mail since 1982 or 1983 at the same address as the reply-to header. I find
    it hard to believe that they paid someone 16,000 dollars for web page
    design. A&M pays undergrad student workers $5.50 an hour to program and
    write HTML when they need a break from thinking. For 16K, I hope they
    included something like a DEC alpha. I didn't think so. Is there a way to
    get on the list of consultants so that I can make some money during a spare
    weekend?
    
    David Semon
    
    Reply:
    Congratulations on your capitalist instincts! As a taxpayer, I'm very concerned by the amount of money spent on such a simple task. I have to admit, my entrepreneurial instincts, like yours, have also led me to ponder how I can get a slice of that pie.

    Subject:  Unofficial School Page comments.
       Date:  Wed, 11 Dec 1996 14:09:02 -0500 (EST)
       From:  GPOWELL@InfoAve.Net
         To:  tim@pisd.org
    
    I tried to get into PISD's 'official' web page, but it seems it is down (and
    has been for at least two days).  I have a good friend that works as a
    computer technician within PISD and the stories I hear from that person
    parallel what I read in your forum.
    
    The price tag quoted for their web page was nothing short of a rip-off.  We
    have local companies assisting us with web pages (along with kids from the
    schools) and we haven't spent that much for the whole district yet!
    
    Keep up the good work.  I know where to go to keep up with events back at home!
    

    Subject:  Unofficial School Page Comments
    Date:     Fri, 13 Dec 1996 23:15:04 -0600
    From:     Olen 
    To:       tim@pisd.org
    
    I like your page very much, as one who does programming for a living, as
    well as DBA work, I must commend you on the bandwidth saving features
    you have on your page.  There is nothing more irritating than waiting 30
    seconds for a page to load.
    
    The comments and information you provide is what we are lacking in the
    North Side Independent School District in San Antonio.  We must all be
    very vigilant about what is happening in our schools.  The faddish
    nature of modern education leaves one to wonder what would happen if we
    attempted to evaluate other, every day, tasks using the same
    methodology?  For example if we only rated the ability of the mechanic
    that works on our car on the amount of effort and personal growth he, or
    she, gained while repairing the breaks on our automobile rather than if
    the breaks now stop the car, would that be satisfactory?  I think not.
    
    Again let me congratulate you on a fine service you are providing and on
    the Big C you earned, I was made aware of your page by the C-NEWS
    mailing list.  Keep up the good work.
    
            Olen Kline
    
    

    Subject: Weird Stuff in PISD
    Date:    Mon, 03 Feb 1997 00:41:27 -0600
    From:    [name withheld by request]
    To:      timw@airmail.net
    
    I'd like to know why teachers give out so much homework.  What are they
    doing in the classrooms?  Do they expect everyone not to have a life? 
    As a parent of one elementary student and one secondary student, I find
    that some nights that's all we're doing around the house.  It's not like
    their getting homework in one subject per night, sometimes they have
    homework in every subject, every night.  Do they really think the
    parents and kids appreciate this?  Maybe more needs to be done AT school
    instead of at home!
    
    My name is [withheld] but please don't print it.   Thanks!
    

    Subject: 
    Date:   Wed, 29 Jan 1997 23:18:43 +0000
    From:   Teresa Masters 
    To:     timw@airmail.net
    
    I have just read your material, and I wonder why so rigid?  There are 
    already too many lemmings, it should not be so fearful to give 
    children the opportunity to see that there are many ways to a valid 
    solution.
    

    Subject:       Civil discourse and conventions of English
    Date:          Mon, 28 Apr 1997 09:02:16 -0700
    From:          Steve Ferrara 
    Organization:  Maryland State Dept. of Education
    To:            tim@pisd.org
    
    Congratulations on the coverage your Web Page received in Ed Week this
    week!  I enjoyed browsing through your page.
    
    I understand your response to the unpleasant comments you got from
    tenchi@airmail.net, but would like to offer a comment.  You chide this
    commenter for lack of civility in a rather uncivil tone.  You also
    criticize his/her errors in conventions of English, even though your Web
    Page section on integrated curriculum incorrectly uses "it's" twice in
    place of "its."  Finally, you warn readers that obscenities are edited
    out of the page; however, this commenter uses the very vulgar term,
    "*****."
    
    Sometimes vacuous and nasty comments like those of tenchi@airmail.net
    are best left alone....
    
    Reply:
    You were right on target with some of your comments - and the changes have been made. Thanks!
    Subject:  Weird Stuff in PISD
    Date:     Tue, 27 May 1997 20:33:52 -0500
    From:     ********** <****@*****>
    To:       timw@airmail.net
    
    Anytime there is a discussion of their practices such as 
    block scheduling or Sophomores playing varsity, the administration
    condemns the teacher or coach and stifles their input. 
    Empowerment is not a term practiced by the Plano Independent 
    School district in any form or degree. 
    
    please keep my name private, they do like to get even also!!!
    

    Subject: Harvey Hotel
       Date:  Sun, 27 Jul 1997 21:43:53 -0500
       From: "anonymous" <*****@*****.***>
         To: tim@pisd.org
    
    I would ask that I be kept anonymous but I am disturbed about something. 
    Last week the PISD held it's annual SEEII Workshop at the Harvey Hotel. 
    Diane Allison the coordinator for the Plano Regional Dayschool for the Deaf
    for PISD actually stayed the week at the Hotel.  Not only did she have a
    room, but a suite for the enitire week.  This strikes me as odd since she
    should be coming into Plano for work everyday anyway.